Rare Earth

TBA21 Vienna

16_RareEarth_Roger_Hiorns_Untitled_TBA21-Augarten_2015_Joe_Clark_1467_CMYK.jpg

Roger Hiorns, Ohne Titel, 2012, Ausstellungsansicht, Nimbus-Militärhelikoptermotor, Feuer und Jugend

Roger Hiorns, Untitled, 2012, installation view, Nimbus military helicopter engine, fire and youth

Curated by Boris Ondreička and Nadim Samman, Rare Earth at TBA21 announces itself as ‘nothing less than an attempt to define the spirit of our age: an exhibition relating myth, identity and cosmology to current advances in technology.’ To fulfill this purposefully overblown claim the approach taken by the curators is a didactic one: 17 artists are each paired with 17 rare earth elements. These elements, found within such ubiquitous objects as electric motors, LED displays and fluorescent lamps, are key for the technological support of contemporary human life – yet their extraction from the earth also has dramatic environmental effects and ethical consequences.

The exhibition begins not with inorganic matter but with organic life, albeit life rendered inert: a nude male in Auguste Rodin’s ‘thinker’ pose is perched on an engine with a small flame on its tail for Roger Hiorns’ Untitled (2012) and a motionless bearded dragon lizard is trapped in a perspex chamber in Iain Ball’s Neodymium (Energy Pangea) (2011). Taking a different approach towards representing life, a room-sized installation anthropomorphizes the earth itself: Marguerite Humeau’s REQUIEM FOR HARLEY WARREN “Screams from Hell” (2015) emits sounds mimicking the groans and shrieks that erupt from fissures in the earth’s crust. While this installation explicitly employs at least two rare earth elements, Erbium and Neodymium, many works refer to their elements metaphorically; The Otolith Group’s Anathema (2011) is a characteristically abstract video installation which takes liquid crystals as inspiration.

As might be expected when single works by so many artists are matched one-to-one with concepts they are supposed to illustrate, the exhibition splinters at times into a collection of same-sized fragments. One of Oliver Laric’s series of Polyeurethane double-faced Sun Tzu heads (Sun Tzu Janus, 2013), and an adjacent mandala wall mural by Suzanne Treister (Rare Earth, 2014), here seem ins­trumentalized and simplified to illustrate concepts of ‘war’ and ‘esotericism’. While both Laric’s and Treister’s work deals heavily with those respective subjects, they do so by complicating rather than simply representing them.

Giorgio-Griffa,-Obliquo_CMYK.jpg

Giorgio Griffa, Obliquo, 1975, Acrylfarbe auf Leinwand

Giorgio Griffa, Obliquo, 1975, Acrylic on canvas

The strength of the show’s premise is the notion that technology doesn’t progress according to a predetermined goal but is shaped by power and belief structures. Yet some works come across as unquestioning proponents of technological determinism. The most mystifyingly linear take on historical progress is Arseniy Zhilyaev’s pentagram-shaped vitrine, Cobblestone Weapon of the Proletariat (2015), which contains tools of liberation throughout human existence – from iron swords and pitchforks to mobile phones.

Positioned in its own room at the very back of the exhibition is Camille Henrot’s brilliant video Grosse Fatigue (2013). Rather than form the 17th component of the exhibition it serves as its culmination. Henrot’s video is essentially a creation story: the history of the universe narrated in spoken-word poetry over footage of humans interacting with nature. Rather than charting from A to B (pitchfork to nanochip), the video rejoices in the complexity of evolution, both biological and technological, and presents a welcome non-Western-centric notion of progress. A circle motif recurs throughout the video, inscribing a non-linear historical arc rather than the straight arrow of the man/machine dichotomy.

In a 2014 article in frieze titled The Stories They Need, Kaelen Wilson-Goldie noticed a common thread in recent artistic practice: a fascination with ethnographic research and the adopting (or parroting) of the work of social scientists – the ‘Anthropological turn’. Rare Earth puts forth what can be seen as a parallel trajectory, a ‘Geo­logical Turn.’ Henrot’s work, which is discussed in Wilson-Goldie’s essay, is perhaps the key to understanding how both ten­dencies function in tandem. In the Anthropocene Era, when human life has so drastically altered earth’s ecology, right-minded geo­logical studies must also be anthropological ones, and vice versa.

Elvia Wilk is a writer and editor living in Berlin. She is a contributing editor at Rhizome and publications editor for transmediale, Berlin.

Issue 19

First published in Issue 19

May 2015

Most Read

Remembering the pioneering composer, visionary thinker, multimedia artist and techno-utopian, who died in May
Jennifer Piejko's guide to the best current shows in LA
Ei Arakawa work stolen from Skulptur Projekte Münster; Richard Mosse arrested; three men charged over counterfeit...
Joyce Pensato, Landscape Mickey, 2017. Courtesy: Lisson Gallery, London
Lisson Gallery, London, UK
Coinciding with Refugee Week, and her film Hear Her Singing screening at the Southbank Centre, the artist shares some...
Gilda Williams visits the first edition of the ARoS Triennial in Aarhus, Denmark
The Haitian Revolution as a lesson in corporate leadership and meeting the 'prophet of the Anthropocene': what to read...
Creative Time launches series of protest flags; photographer Khadija Saye reported as a victim of London's Grenfell...
A recent retrospective at the Museo Ettore Fico in Turin establishes the overlooked importance of a ‘total artist’
The third edition of the London performance festival makes the case for collective action in an age of political...
A past winner of the Frieze Writer’s Prize, Zoe Pilger on the books and experiences that have influenced her as a writer
A guide to the best projects included in Skulptur Projekte Münster 2017
For the first in a series of our editors’ initial impressions from documenta 14 Kassel, Pablo Larios on the Neue...
Art sees itself as facing a crisis of legitimation – can this account for claims to 'authenticity' being made in shows...

An interview with the late artist on the unique classification system he devised to organize his books
The independent curator on 25 years in the arts

Latest Magazines

frieze magazine

April 2017

frieze magazine

May 2017

frieze magazine

June – August 2017