Don’t Show That!

Contemporary African artists respond to prejudice and homophobia

muholi_busi-mdaki-and-malesedi-nthute.gif

Zanele Muholi, Busi Maaki and Malsedi Nthute, Katlehong, Johannesburg. From the series 'Being', 2007. Courtesy: Michael Stevenson Gallery, Cape Town, and the artist.

Zanele Muholi, Busi Maaki and Malsedi Nthute, Katlehong, Johannesburg. From the series 'Being', 2007. Courtesy: Michael Stevenson Gallery, Cape Town, and the artist.

For every Joseph Beuys and Yves Klein there is a fascist doppelgänger who also believes in the transformative potential of paint on the human body. In 1999, shortly after trespassing onto a white farmer’s property southeast of Johannesburg, Moses Nkosi, 21, was stripped, his naked body painted silver by the landowner and his black assistant. An anomalous brand of vigilantism, this was repeated again a year later when a 14-year-old girl accused of shoplifting underwear was similarly stripped and painted by a white store manager and her black assistant. Paint, however, is of course not a prerequisite for the enactment of prejudice.

In 1995, Zimbabwean president Robert Mugabe described homosexuals as ‘worse than dogs and pigs’. Although strongly criticized, Mugabe’s views enjoy widespread support in various parts of Africa. Last year, a Ugandan politician with ties to the US evangelical movement introduced a bill proposing the death penalty for ‘aggravated homosexuality’. Earlier this year, a Malawian court convicted two men, Steven Monjeza and Tiwonge Chimbalanga, of gross indecency for performing a symbolic marriage ceremony – their 14-year prison term was later rescinded by presidential pardon following pressure from the United Nations. Gay sex is still illegal in 37 African states.

Intolerance is obviously not peculiar to Africa – the oil slick of homophobia, racism and xenophobia reaches everywhere. Neither does every creative act bounded by the continental lasso that is Africa necessarily concern itself with countering the tawdry facts of discrimination. Even amongst those artists who directly engage bigotry, approaches vary.

Athi-Patra Ruga and Zanele Muholi offer potent examples. Born in 1984 and trained as a fashion designer, in person Ruga is a disarming figure. Mostly it’s his laugh, a spluttering combustion engine of enthusiasm – but he wasn’t laughing when, in 2008, he read about Nwabisa Ngcukana, a lanky 25-year-old Johannesburg resident who was assaulted for wearing a miniskirt by taxi drivers and roadside hawkers at a busy taxi rank. ‘I think they were trying to teach her a lesson,’ a witness cheerfully told a journalist after Ngcukana’s ordeal, which included being paraded naked and doused in alcohol. Ruga’s response to the attack, which happened shortly before Mozambican national Ernesto Alfabeto Nhamuave was torched by a xenophobic South African mob sparking nationwide anti-immigrant violence, was an improvized performance that tempted the same fate as Ngcukana.

In the guise of his alter ego, Beiruth (picture a camp Star Trek alien with haute-couture sensibilities and hair issues) Ruga wandered around a Cape Town taxi rank at night. People mostly stared at his Leigh Bowery-like fantasy creation in red stilettos but the performance did have a purpose: Ruga wanted to take a taxi to Atlantis, a far-flung township named after a mythical nowhere. He also wanted to assert, as he put it afterwards, the right of ‘the autonomous body against that of the sovereign state’. This expression is helpful in explaining Muholi’s work. A self-described ‘activist-photographer’, Muholi’s images of black lesbian culture are at once formal and restrained, participatory and autobiographical. Rotimi Fani-Kayodé, Catherine Opie and Jo Spence are all reliable markers of affinity; less explicitly, Youssef Nabil uses the camera to assert his gay identity in Egypt, where although legal, homosexuality is taboo.

Born in Durban, Muholi received her initial training at the Market Photo Workshop, a modest school of photography founded in 1989 by David Goldblatt. Her first photographs were of Johannesburg’s annual Gay Pride Parade.

Muholi’s practice, which is highlighted in a new book, Faces and Phases (2010), is interesting for the way it challenges South Africa’s overly masculine definition of a socially motivated photography. The artist, whose matted braids are often bundled into a Rastafarian crown, was a founding member of the Forum for the Empowerment of Women (FEW), a Johannesburg-based support organization for black lesbians, bisexuals and transgender women. Her early black and white photography appeared in FEW’s online magazine (mask.org.za) and unflinchingly documented lesbian self-harm, as well as the sadistic practice of ‘curative rape’ by males. While her photography has its doctrinaire moments, Muholi can also be tender and lyrical, without extinguishing the subversive heft of her project.

Nonetheless, and rehearsing an age-old power game, South Africa’s minister of arts and culture, Lulama Xingwana, cried ‘pornography’ when she first encountered Muholi’s photographs last year after being invited to open her exhibition – which she refused to do, a decision that occasioned national debate. (Rather disturbingly, in the lead up to the story breaking in March the minister dispatched four legal representatives to consult with experts and determine if the work was pornographic. Their findings are unknown.) Two edifying things emerged out of the Xingwana affair. The first satellites around a familiar thought: state power is dumb, always has been, will always continue to be. The second is no less complicated. Speaking at a Cape Town forum hosted in the aftermath of her most recent run-in with conservative African morality, Muholi stated: ‘My audience is those people who look at two lesbian women in a photo and say that it is a shock: “Oh my God, don’t show that!” That is my audience.’
 

Sean O’Toole is a regular frieze columnist and co-editor of CityScapes, a critical journal for urban enquiry. He lives in Cape Town, South Africa.

Issue 133

First published in Issue 133

September 2010

Most Read

Garage Museum of Contemporary Art, Moscow, Russia
Tate Modern, London
London’s fourth plinth artists announced; a new fund to protect cultural heritage in war-torn areas
Annika Eriksson, The Social, 2017, wallpaper and objects on a shelf, 500 x 450 cm. Courtesy: The artist and Moderna Museet, Malmö
 
Moderna Museet, Malmö, Sweden
Paul Scheerbart, Nusi-Pusi, 1912. Courtesy: Berlinische Galerie/Kai-Annett Becker
From a short history of plagiarism to Trisha Brown's walk: what to read this weekend
Q. What is art for? A. To tell us where we are.
The work of filmmaker James N. Kienitz Wilkins on the occasion of his inclusion in the 2017 Whitney Biennial film...
Trisha Brown has died, aged 80; two new appointments at London’s ICA; controversy at the Whitney
A round-up of the best shows to see in the city ahead of this week’s Art Basel Hong Kong
How should the artistic community respond when an art space, explicitly or implicitly, associates itself with right-...
Charlie Fox on a new translation of Hervé Guibert's chronicle of love, lust and drug-addled longing
Three highlights from the New York festival promoting emerging filmmakers
Whitney Museum of American Art, New York, USA
A report and the highlights from a show themed around fluidity, flux, botany and the subterranean
From growing protests over the gentrification of Boyle Heights to Schimmel leaving Hauser & Wirth, the latest from...
kurimanzutto, Mexico City, Mexico
Migros Museum für Gegenwartskunst, Zurich, Switzerland
The body is a troubled thing ...
Sir Howard Hodgkin dies aged 84; finalists for Berlin’s Preis der Nationalgalerie 2017 announced

From the Women's Strike to a march that cancels itself out: what to read this weekend
The most interesting works in the IFFR’s Short Film section all grappled with questions of truth, honesty and...
With the reissue of their eponymous debut album, revisiting the career of legendary Berlin art project / punk band Die...
Galeria Jaqueline Martins, São Paulo, Brazil 

Tramway, Glasgow, UK
A work by self-taught artist Martín Ramírez
Munich’s Haus der Kunst embroiled in Scientology scandal; Martín Ramírez to inaugurate the new ICA LA
If politics today obsesses over the policing of borders, art in France is enacting multiple crossings
A new video installation from Richard Mosse investigates the refugee crisis
Gustav Metzger has died aged 90; director of the Met resigns
What draws us to certain stories, and why do we retell them? 
It’s time that the extraordinary life and work of Anya Berger was acknowledged

Latest Magazines

frieze magazine

Nov - Dec 2016

frieze magazine

Jan - Feb 2017

frieze magazine

March 2017