Outrage over Hiring a White Woman as African Art Curator Misunderstands Expertise

The argument that ancestral connection offers a natural grasp of the complex histories and aesthetics of African art is profoundly misguided

The recent decision taken by New York’s Brooklyn Museum to appoint a white woman, Kristen Windmuller-Luna, as its new Consulting Curator of African Art, has revealed fault-lines cutting across American society and its art world. Despite the fact that Windmuller-Luna is a historian of African arts and architecture with a Ph.D. from Princeton University (where I supervised her thesis) and a lectureship at Columbia University, among other credentials, many people took to social media to criticize the appointment, arguing that the role should have gone to a person of colour. And given how depressingly white US art institutions remain, in spite of the growth of the country’s non-white population, the outrage about lack of diversity in professional museum jobs is certainly warranted.

Brooklyn Museum, New York. Courtesy: Brooklyn Museum, New York; photograph: Jon Grizzle

Brooklyn Museum, New York. Courtesy: Brooklyn Museum, New York; photograph: Jon Grizzle

Brooklyn Museum, New York. Courtesy: Brooklyn Museum, New York; photograph: Jon Grizzle

Consider the 2015 Andrew W. Mellon Foundation study which found that only four percent of curators in US museums are black – confirmation of an indefensible status quo. And you need only look to a long history of racial discrimination and marginalization in all spheres of American society to see that the necessary work of overcoming its devastating impact on African American art and artists is far from complete.

Yet, the most vehement outrage over the Brooklyn Museum appointment was not really about diversification. Rather, it was about ownership of African art, which, at best, is misguided. What do I mean?

61.33_threequarter_left_sl1_img.jpg

Kuba (Bushoong subgroup), Ndop Portrait of King Mishe miShyaang maMbul, 19th century, camwood powder, 50 x 20 x 22 cm. Courtesy: Brooklyn Museum, Gift of Mr. and Mrs. Alastair B. Martin, Mrs. Donald M. Oenslager, Mr. and Mrs. Robert E. Blum, and the Mrs. Florence A. Blum Fund; Creative Commons

Kuba (Bushoong subgroup), Ndop Portrait of King Mishe miShyaang maMbul, 19th century, wood, 50 x 20 x 22 cm. Courtesy: Brooklyn Museum, Gift of Mr. and Mrs. Alastair B. Martin; Mrs. Donald M. Oenslager; Mr. and Mrs. Robert E. Blum; the Mrs. Florence A Blum Fund; Creative Commons

Besides Windmuller-Luna, in the same announcement at the end of last month, the Brooklyn Museum hired another curator – Drew Sawyer, a white male – for its photography department. No one asked why Sawyer was hired to curate photography. A few mentioned him only to highlight the overwhelming whiteness of recent appointments across US museums. We might conclude that most of the Brooklyn Museum bashers saw little problem with Sawyer’s appointment because photography is white people’s domain. The curator, you might say, is at home with photography. But not so with Windmuller-Luna, who could not make any ancestral claims to Africa or African art. She was seen as illegitimate, an interloper, or worse. And that shows us everything that is wrong with the criticism.

A reasonable diversity campaign against the Brooklyn Museum ought to have focused equally on the two hires, if the point was to argue that the museum needed to make its curatorial staff less white (note, however, that nearly half of the Brooklyn Museum’s curatorial staff are non-white). But, once the argument congealed around the question of a white woman being appointed to tell the story of African people, it ceased to be about curatorial diversity, and turned into a battle for African heritage, about ancestral claims. And this is where one might blame the blockbuster film, Ryan Coogler’s Black Panther (2018), or rather a misreading of its infamous museum scene.

Ryan Coogler, Black Panther, 2018, film still. Courtesy: Marvel Studios

Ryan Coogler, Black Panther, 2018, film still. Courtesy: Marvel Studios

Ryan Coogler, Black Panther, 2018, film still. Courtesy: Marvel Studios

As part of the film’s heist plot, set in the ‘Museum of Great Britain’, Killmonger, the film’s black villain, confronts a curator, a white woman, about European colonial expropriation of African art and material cultures that now fill museums like hers. Killmonger and his accomplices go on to ‘liberate’ one of the museum’s objects. The scene has been invoked ad nauseam by the Brooklyn Museum’s detractors in order to galvanize outrage against the appointment.

To its critics, the Brooklyn Museum missed Black Panther’s teachable moment. It repeated the fictional museum’s mistake by hiring its own white female curator, an ill-fitted, haughty expert who cannot truly understand Africa and African art. Yet the crucial lesson of that scene is not about the curator’s race; were she black, would Killmonger have given her a fist bump and thanked the museum for keeping his ancestor’s looted hammer? The power of that scene in Black Panther lies in its critique of Western museums as symbols and products of colonialism and repositories of empire’s loot.

Yoruba. Egungun Dance Costume, mid-20th century, wood, cotton, wool, aluminum, 140 x 15 x 160 cm. Courtesy: Brooklyn Museum, gift of Sam Hilu; Creative Commons

Yoruba. Egungun Dance Costume, mid-20th century, wood, cotton, wool, aluminum, 140 x 15 x 160 cm. Courtesy: Brooklyn Museum, gift of Sam Hilu; Creative Commons

Yoruba, Egungun Dance Costume, mid-20th century, wood, cotton, wool, aluminium, 140 x 15 x 160 cm. Courtesy: Brooklyn Museum, gift of Sam Hilu; Creative Commons

The outrage over the Brooklyn Museum’s appointment only makes sense in the context of claims to cultural ownership and protests over cultural appropriation; that is, who can legitimately claim the heritage embodied in the museum’s African art objects? Deeply felt and meaningful as these issues might be to people of colour and marginalized groups, they must not be conflated with the question of who could or should curate, teach and study African art.

To argue, as many have, that a person of colour, by dint of her ancestry, would naturally grasp the intricate histories, and complex aesthetics of historical African art is to misunderstand the work of the curator or scholar. It is to ignore or belittle the rigorous professional training, research and scholarship expected of museum curators – work that comes from acquired knowledge and experience. Work that anyone, black or white, that is so driven, capable and duly trained could aspire to. The Brooklyn Museum has defended Windmuller-Luna as qualified for the job and they are right to do so.

69.39.2_sl1_img.jpg

Mende, Janus Faced (Ndoli jowei) Mask of the Sande Society, 19th century, wood, glass, 40 x 28 x 30 cm. Courtesy: Brooklyn Museum, Robert B. Woodward Memorial Fund; Creative Commons

Mende, Janus Faced (Ndoli jowei) Mask of the Sande Society, 19th century, wood, glass, 40 x 28 x 30 cm. Courtesy: Brooklyn Museum, Robert B. Woodward Memorial Fund; Creative Commons

The controversy points to a much more fundamental problem. Like the art industry, art history has not done enough to diversify its student and faculty demography. Few students of colour earn the doctoral degrees now expected by most museums for entry-level curatorial positions. More sobering still, far fewer people of colour study the historical African art that still forms the core of museums’ African collections. If we wish to diversify curatorial positions in African art, graduate programmes must overcome old bad habits of overlooking non-white applicants; and young people of colour must be recruited and given the support to pursue this field of study.

Main image: Kuba (Bushoong subgroup), Mwaash aMbooy Mask, late 19th or early 20th century,  hide, paint, plant fibres, textile, shell, glass, wood, hair, feathers, 56 x 51 x 46 cm. Courtesy: Brooklyn Museum, Museum Expedition 1922, Robert B. Woodward Memorial Fund; Creative Commons

Chika Okeke-Agulu is Professor of African and African Diaspora Art, Princeton University.

Most Read

If artificial intelligence were ever to achieve sentience, could it feasibly produce art? (And would it be good?)
The punk activist-artists have been charged with disruption after they charged the field during the France vs Croatia...
27 educators are taking the London gallery to an employment tribunal, demanding that they be recognized as employees
In further news: Glasgow School of Art to be rebuilt; Philadelphia Museum of Art gets a Frank Gehry-designed restaurant
Highlights from Condo New York 2018 and Commonwealth and Council at 47 Canal: the summer shows to see
Knussen’s music laid out each component as ‘precarious, vulnerable, exposed’ – and his conducting similarly worked from...
Nods to the game in World Cup celebrations show how dance has gone viral – but unwittingly instrumentalized for...
‘You can’t reason with him but you can ridicule him’ – lightweight as it is, Trump Baby is a win for art as a...
Anderson and partner Juman Malouf are sorting through the treasures of the celebrated Kunsthistorisches Museum for...
From Capote to Basquiat, the pop artist’s glittering ‘visual diary’ of the last years of his life is seen for the first...
‘When I opened Monika Sprüth Galerie, only very few German gallerists represented women artists’
Can a ragtag cluster of artists, curators and critics really push back against our ‘bare’ art world?
In further news: German government buys Giambologna at the eleventh hour; LACMA’s new expansion delayed
Gucci and Frieze present film number two in the Second Summer of Love series, focusing on the history of acid house
Judges described the gallery’s GBP£20 million redevelopment by Jamie Fobert Architects as ‘deeply intelligent’ and a ‘...
Is the lack of social mobility in the arts due to a self-congratulatory conviction that the sector represents the...
The controversial intellectual suggests art would be better done at home – she should be careful what she wishes for
Previously unheard music on Both Directions At Once includes blues as imposing as the saxophonist would ever record
In further news: Macron reconsiders artist residencies; British Council accused of censorship; V&A to host largest...
In our devotion to computation and its predictive capabilities are we rushing blindly towards our own demise?
Arts subjects are increasingly marginalized in the UK curriculum – but the controversial intellectual suggests art is...
An exhibition of performances at Foksal Gallery Foundation, Warsaw, unfolds the rituals of sexual encounters
An art historian explains what the Carters’s takeover of the Paris museum says about art, race and power
Artist Andrea Fraser’s 2016 in Museums, Money and Politics lifts the lid on US museum board members and...
The Ruhrtriennale arts festival disinvited the Scottish hip-hop trio for their pro-Palestinian politics, then u-turned
The Baltimore’s director on why correcting the art historical canon is not only right but urgent for museums to remain...
Serpentine swimmers complain about Christo’s floating pyramid; and Hermitage’s psychic cat is a World Cup oracle: the...
The largest mural in Europe by the artist has been hidden for 30 years in an old storage depot – until now
Alumni Martin Boyce, Karla Black, Duncan Campbell and Ciara Phillips on the past and future of Charles Rennie...
In further news: po-mo architecture in the UK gets heritage status; Kassel to buy Olu Oguibe’s monument to refugees
The frieze columnist's first novel is an homage to, and embodiment of, the late, great Kathy Acker
60 years after the celebrated Brutalist architect fell foul of local authorities, a Berlin Unité d’Habitation apartment...
The British artist and Turner Prize winner is taking on the gun advocacy group at a time of renewed debate around arms...
The central thrust of the exhibition positions Sicily as the fulcrum of geopolitical conflicts over migration, trade,...
The Carters’s museum takeover powers through art history’s greatest hits – with a serious message about how the canon...
The 20-metre-high Mastaba finally realizes the artist and his late wife Jeanne-Claude’s design
‘What is being exhibited at Manifesta, above all, is Palermo itself’
With the 12th edition of the itinerant European biennial opening in Palermo, what do local artists, curators and...
In the age of Brexit, why Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn’s pledge to return the ‘stolen’ Parthenon marbles has never been...
The curators seem set to ask, ‘how civilized is the world’s current state of affairs?’
US true crime series Unsolved takes two formative pop cultural events to explore their concealed human stories and...

On View

Latest Magazines

frieze magazine

April 2018

frieze magazine

May 2018

frieze magazine

June - August 2018