The Turner Prize & Identity Politics

A response to some of the responses

‘“Identity issues” – is there a bleaker phrase in art? Artists, stop telling us about yourselves. Look up! #TurnerPrize #pious #worthy’ So wrote art critic and broadcaster Waldemar Januszczak in one of a series of tweets in response to the announcement of this year’s Turner Prize shortlist. He’s not the only one to have made a troubling comment on the role of identity politics in the nomination of artists Hurvin Anderson, Andrea Büttner, Lubaina Himid and Rosalind Nashashibi (full disclosure, my colleague, frieze co-editor Dan Fox, is one of the prize judges). The online arts publication ArtLyst also chose an outrageous headline for their article on the nominees, running: ‘Turner Prize Shortlist Reveals Obscure Multicultural Pick & Mix’. 

screen-shot-2017-05-04-at-14.44.jpg

The headline to a story on the 2017 Turner Prize shortlist on www.artlyst.com

I’ll tell you what I find bleak – this kind of complacency around diversity and worthiness in the arts. Though the ArtLyst article includes fairly innocuous descriptions of each artist, indicating that the headline is probably unintentionally ham-fisted, its framing remains problematic in its reference to identity. To liken the selected nominees to a ‘pick & mix’ evokes the image of a mixed bag of goods or confectionary. In its most troubling potential reading, the phrase depicts the artists as an assortment of shapes, colours or flavours, all of which carry associations of racial ‘types’. It’s a headline that implies that the artists were primarily selected for their cultural variety, not their long and rich careers as artists, that their ethnicity is the salient factor behind their nomination, rather than the quality of their work. To label them as obscure is silly. Each has had at least one major local or international exhibition in the last year, all have work in important public collections and are, or have been, represented by influential commercial galleries. Himid, who one could argue out of all the nominees is the least well-known, has had, this year alone, two retrospective exhibitions in UK public institutions (Modern Art Oxford and Spike Island), and her work was included in another large group show, ‘The Place is Here’, that just closed at Nottingham Contemporary. Nashashibi’s films are currently on view in documenta 14 in Athens; Büttner will have a solo show later this year at the Hammer Museum in Los Angeles; Anderson recently had a solo show at the Art Gallery of Ontario, Canada. They are not household names, for sure, but if that’s what counts as obscurity then I need to call my agent pronto!

But whilst the article discusses these artists as 'unknowns', the headline may be read as implying more than their relative public profiles. It yokes together the concepts of multiculturalism and obscurity, suggesting, intentionally or not, that the one idea necessarily entails the other. Multicultural politics are often seen as the concern of marginalized ethnic groups, those most in need of better political or social representation. According to this NIMBYist logic, beloved of neo-conservatives, multiculturalism is obscure because it is unimportant to the cultural majority and unhappily imposed upon them by the few. Multiculturalism also carries the taint of liberal elitism and so implies intellectual, academic or economic removal from the realities of everyday life.

gazacropped.jpg

Rosalind Nashashibi, Electrical Gaza, 2015, film still. Courtesy: the artist

Rosalind Nashashibi, Electrical Gaza, 2015, film still. Courtesy: the artist

The assumed obscurity of the multicultural thus pulls in two different directions: on the one hand it represents the culturally insignificant, on the other, those who are too culturally significant, because they are privileged by the powerful. In the context of the Turner Prize nomination, the phrase ‘obscure multicultural pick & mix’ oscillates between these two ideas, suggesting both the minority backgrounds of the nominees and the rarefied concerns of the judges. At the risk of sounding rather rarefied myself, these polarized meanings put me in mind of Roland Barthes’s parody, in 1957, of the conservative critic who complains about a difficult play: ‘I don’t understand, therefore you are all stupid’. According to Barthes’s imagined malcontent, whatever can’t be readily understood or doesn’t conform to my interests, is dumb, even if that’s because it’s too sophisticated, or simply unfamiliar. Either way, the problem can never be with the one who feels challenged. In regard to the Turner Prize responses the phrase might be: ‘I don’t feel represented, therefore this is irrelevant’. Given these highly charged associations, the pairing of multiculturalism and obscurity is unfortunate.

Let’s take a moment to unpack Januszczak’s tweet. Well, first of all, what kind of person would take to Twitter to make sweeping remarks on urgent and sensitive socio-cultural issues? I’m drawing no obvious comparisons, as I don’t want to encourage Jancuszczak to enter politics.

screen_shot_2017-05-04_at_15.40.26.png

A series of tweets from Waldemar Januszczak’s Twitter account reacting to the 2017 Turner Prize shortlist on 3 May 2017

A series of tweets from Waldemar Januszczak’s Twitter account reacting to the 2017 Turner Prize shortlist on 3 May 2017

His singling out of the phrase ‘identity issues’ is an incredibly reductive response to a shortlist of four very different artists. Whilst it’s true that identity does factor into the work of each nominee, some place more emphasis on this than others and each approaches the subject in distinct ways. Himid, perhaps the artist most explicitly associated with identity politics, was at the vanguard of the black British arts movement in the 1970s and ’80s, and was nominated for figurative paintings exploring the impact of colonialism on displaced individuals. Quite differently, Anderson approaches black British identity in his paintings through abstraction, interiors or landscapes. Büttner, to the extent that she could be said to explore identity at all, has done so through her work with Carmelite nuns and displays of native plant life, although the judges singled out her use of anachronistic techniques such as woodcutting as amongst the reasons for her nomination. Nashashibi is a filmmaker whose nominated video, Electrical Gaza (2016) uses animation and live footage to play with truth and falsehood in the Arab-Israeli conflict, a context suffused with identity issues, but not necessarily the primary topic of the work.

electrical-gaza-1540x866.jpg

Rosalind Nashashibi, Electrical Gaza, 2015, film still. Courtesy: the artist

Rosalind Nashashibi, Electrical Gaza, 2015, film still. Courtesy: the artist

Januszczak’s argument seems to be that in dealing with identity artists are fundamentally falling into the trap of narcissism. Are ‘identity issues’ so easily reduced to artistic navel gazing? At the risk of stating the obvious, identity politics are primarily concerned with widespread social and structural issues of inequality, even where they are expressed through the personal. Racism, misogyny, homophobia and class identity are all collective rather than singular struggles and any attempt to draw on biography often serves to situate the individual in relation to their social context.

More than that, artists exploring identity have done much to displace the role of the individual: far from confirming narcissism, the idea that identities are culturally constructed, relative and discursive, would seem to have much more to do with them looking at the broader world of visual culture. Think of Cindy Sherman drawing upon cinema tropes to explore representations femininity, or Himid’s images of colonial history, dress and custom: these aren’t self-portraits in any ordinary sense, but journeys into the history of art, cinema, economics and literature. And, turning back to my phrase ‘I don’t understand, therefore this is irrelevant’, isn’t Januszczak’s own narcissism the spectre haunting his tweet? Identity issues bore him because they are not his primary concern and therefore he finds no urgency or interest in such work. As the young folk say, ‘check your privilege’.

20160520102844-anderson_is-it-ok-to-be-black_2016.jpg

Hurvin Anderson, Is It Ok To Be Black?, 2016. Courtesy: the artist and Thomas Dane Gallery, London

Hurvin Anderson, Is It Ok To Be Black?, 2016. Courtesy: the artist and Thomas Dane Gallery, London

There’s also a striking irony in his complaint about worthiness (#worthy). Whilst Jancuszczak implies that the list has a joyless focus on political reform, isn’t he the one making the much more overt and distinctly sour call for cultural change? Where’s the joy in his bad-tempered tweets? His hashtag invokes the received opinion that art about social issues is, necessarily, dry and dull and presents a picture of cultural progressives as party-poopers. These are such well-worn conservative clichés that they’ve even inspired attempts to reclaim them: for example, in her blog Feministkilljoys, Sara Ahmed encourages her readers to embrace the stereotype of the humourless women’s libber. The implication behind the accusation of worthiness is that happiness and pleasure depend on maintaining the status quo, never mind that this involves a great deal of unhappiness and neglect for others. Anyway, I see a huge amount of playfulness in Himid’s celebrations of black creativity, beauty in Anderson’s paintings and mordant humour in Büttner’s trays of wilting Welsh moss. And if you want art with vitality, you could do worse than grappling with the life and death questions raised in the films Nashashibi made in Gaza. Jancuszczak also tweets that these do-gooders have nominated certain artists (clearly Anderson and Himid) simply because of their age and longstanding commitment to issues of identity, indicating that they are undeserving other than because of their longevity. 

abu-13-060-1024x717.jpg

Andrea Büttner, I want to let the work fall down, 2005, woodcut on paper, 99 x 140 cm. Courtesy: the artist, Hollybush Gardens, London and David Kordansky, Los Angeles

Andrea Büttner, I want to let the work fall down, 2005, woodcut on paper, 99 x 140 cm. Courtesy: the artist, Hollybush Gardens, London and David Kordansky, Los Angeles

Of course, it’s difficult not to hear echoes of Brexit Britain and protectionism in these responses. In the call to turn away from identity issues, isn’t there just a hint of sticking to what we know and recognise? Doesn't the mention of moral improvement sound an awful lot like lazy complaints about political correctness? Adrian Searle certainly seemed to anticipate this scenario when he enthusiastically described the shortlist as a ‘cosmopolitan rebuff to Brexit provincialism’. Cosmopolitans are also, of course, a delicious cocktail and certainly taste better and bring more joy than all these sour grapes.

Main image: Lubaina Himid, Navigation Charts, 2017, installation view, Spike Island, Bristol. Courtesy: the artist and Hollybush Gardens, London

Paul Clinton is a writer based in London, UK. He is associate editor of frieze and Frieze Masters Magazine. In 2015 he co-curated the exhibition 'duh? Art & Stupidity' at Focal Point Gallery, Southend-on-Sea, UK.

Most Read

Ahead of its South London Gallery performance, how Tom Phillips’s Irma – a work that questions the genre of opera...
With the opening of the 15th Istanbul Biennial this week, a guide to the best exhibitions around town
Ahead of the openings of EXPO Chicago and the 2017 Chicago Architecture Biennial, a guide to the best exhibitions...
Florine Stettheimer, Beauty Contest: To the Memory of P.T. Barnum, 1924, oil on canvas, 1.2 x 1.5 m. Courtesy: Wadsworth Athenaeum Museum of Art, Hartford, Connecticut and Ettie Stettheimer
The Jewish Museum, New York, USA
Highlights of the exhibitions and performances taking place during Berlin Art Week 
Reflections, a favourite verse, and a new poem dedicated to one of the English language’s most renowned poets of the...
Nicole Eiseman, Sketch for a Fountain (Skizze für einen Brunnen), 2017, Skulptur Projekte 2017, bronze, gips, wasserbecken. Courtesy: Skulptur Projekte Münster
Various venues, Münster, Germany
Buoyed by Manifesta announcing it will dock in the port city in 2020, is Marseille becoming the new LA? 
Ahead of this year’s DC Open and gallery share Okey-Dokey, a round-up of the best shows across the Rhineland cities
From artist Enoch Cheng’s nocturnal balletics to fascist violence in Charlottesville, rethinking the political agency...
Opened 15 months ago but remaining empty until now, the inaugural show at the landmark Palestinian Museum in Birzeit
The dual sides to the city’s Cph Art Week
Queer cringe at the BBC and other diversity dilemmas
Marta Minujín, El Partenón de libros (The Parthenon of Books), 2017, under construction in Kassel as part of documenta 14. Photograph: © Rosa Maria Ruehling
On documenta 14 in Athens and Kassel
Chris Kraus’s biography of the first female ‘Great Writer as Countercultural Hero’
Remembering the artist whose occultist experiments transformed her body and biography into art 
In this microcosm of the disenfranchisement of ‘Late Great Britain’, what use is art?
Public debate around Confederate insignia has little to do with historical fact, and everything to do with collective...
A multi-faceted collaboration between Matthew Barney, Ragnar Kjartansson and the Iceland Dance Company reflects on...
What Luc Besson’s Valerian and a number of recent artists’ 3D films are getting right about our current reality
The removal of the Confederate monuments in Baltimore shows decisiveness after years of inaction – already they stand...
Yayoi Kusama to open her own museum; Confederate monuments removed in Baltimore; David Roberts Art Foundation to leave...
From a tribute to Straub/Huillet to Valerie Massadian’s portrait of teenage motherhood, the turn to real situations and...
Japan’s growing number of art festivals tread a precarious path between state-sponsored leisure-culture and soft-power...
Fifty years after the term was coined, a show in Samos reflects on ‘the unlikely liaison between love and politics’
Arsenale and Giardini, Venice, Italy
SoundCloud has been invaluable to the new music community for both documentation and discovery – now the audio-...
The extraordinary life of the late, great, gallerist and collector Alexander Iolas
Various venues, New York, USA
At a time of instantaneous information and fetishized immersivity, artists are evoking scent as an alchemical, bodily...
With her current show at Gasworks, London, the Kuwaiti artist shares some influential images
Romare Bearden, Pittsburgh Memory, 1964, mixed media collage and graphite on board, 22 x 30 cm. Courtesy: © Romare Bearden Foundation / DACS, London / VAGA, New York 2017
Successfully layering a broader socio-historical narrative onto a period of radical non-conformity, this is an...
With a strong surrealist strain, and including a welcome number of female artists, highlights from the 48th edition of...

Latest Magazines

frieze magazine

May 2017

frieze magazine

June – August 2017

frieze magazine

September 2017