Loose Canons

As museums around the world seek to make their collections and displays more inclusive of non-Western art, how are German institutions responding?

In 1923, André Malraux – a writer and poet who was later France’s Minister of Culture – travelled to Angkor, the ancient capital of the Khmer empire. At the time, archaeological expeditions in Cambodia, sponsored by the French authorities, were plundering Angkor Wat, the city’s largest religious complex: its riches are now housed at the Guimet Museum in Paris. Malraux headed to the recently discovered Banteay Srei temple, seeking artefacts to resell. Upon his return to France, he was accused of removing and keeping a bas-relief from the temple and arrested. Believing he had acted within the law, Malraux contested the charges. The statues, he felt, belonged not to French colonial authorities but to ‘mankind’.

Twenty-five years later, Malraux began to assemble what he came to call his Musée imaginaire, a ‘museum without walls’ recording ‘the common heritage of all mankind’. He started this project – which prefigured later decades’ tendencies toward bold curatorial gestures – at roughly the same time as the biennial model began its expan­sionary trajectory: the São Paulo Biennial was founded in 1951 while 1955 saw the opening of documenta, the Biennale de la Méditerranée in Alexandria and the Ljubljana Biennial of Graphic Arts. If Malraux’s approach makes us feel uneasy, it is because it highlights how humanist universalism was imbricated with cultural plunder – whether symbolic or material. Predicated on a potentially infinite inclusivity, Malraux’s Musée imaginaire embodies the opposing tensions – between inclusion and expansion, centre and periphery – that exist in today’s notions of a ‘global museum’.

In his 1994 article Some Problems in Transcultural Curating, Gerardo Mosquera describes an increasingly internationalized art system’s divisions between the ‘curating west’ and the ‘curated rest’, which experience unequal structures of legitimation, inclusion and connection. During the last two decades, however, attempts have been made to expand the artistic canon to extra-occidental art practices, while others have aimed to undo notions of an existing canon altogether. In 2012, the International Committee for Museums and Collections of Modern Art called for ‘different cultural and epistemological traditions to be reconciled’ within museums of the future. Earlier this year, Okwui Enwezor – the curator of documenta 11, an important benchmark for this global view – was honoured by Essen’s Museum Folkwang for raising ‘a global awareness of art beyond the Euro-American canon’.

bagyi_aung_soe_untitled_framed_46x52x3_cm_ink_on_paper_courtesy_of_gajah_gallery-cmyk.jpg

Bagyi Aung Soe, Untitled, 1987, from the exhibition ‘Misfits‘ at HKW. Courtesy: the artist and Gajah Gallery, Singapore and HKW, Berlin

Bagyi Aung Soe, Untitled, 1987, from the exhibition ‘Misfits‘ at HKW. Courtesy: the artist and Gajah Gallery, Singapore and HKW, Berlin

In Germany, the ‘Global Museum’ programme, launched this year by the Federal Cultural Foundation, seeks to encourage several of the country’s key institutions to ‘redefine their collections from a non-Western perspective’. The exhibition project ‘A Tale of Two Worlds’ examines European and South American postwar artistic movements. It will result in two exhibitions: the first at the MMK Frankfurt later this year; the second at MAMBA, Buenos Aires, in 2018. Also as part of ‘Global Museum’, the show ‘Eccentric Modernism’ will open at K20, Düsseldorf, in April 2018. This exhibition aims to reframe the institution’s existing collections in relation to extra-occidental artistic practices. Lastly, ‘Global Resonances’, due to open at Berlin’s Hamburger Bahnhof in March 2018, likewise seeks to explore what the modernist canon would look like if it were expanded beyond 20th-century European and US models.

A separate, long-term project at Berlin’s Haus der Kulturen der Welt, ‘Kanon-Fragen’ (Canon Questions), which launched in 2016 and will continue until 2019, sets out to examine ‘canonization’ as an institutional operation. The first iteration of this project, ‘Past Disquiet. Narratives and Ghosts from the International Art Exhibition for Palestine, 1978’, revisits the titular show, which was intended to lay the foundations of a ‘museum in exile’ for the Palestinian people. This project encapsulated what its curator Anselm Franke refers to as ‘undead histories’: those lacking sufficient authority to question officially sanctioned narratives, or simply without the financial support or infrastructure to be exhibited in the first place. ‘Past Disquiet’ illustrates the tensions within ‘global’ networks and the problems of access and uneven authority that persist in contemporary art at large.

Currently on display at the Haus der Kulturen der Welt, ‘“Misfits”: Pages from a Loose-leaf Modernity’, curated by David Teh, focuses on three artists whose practices step outside of the canon. The eclectic works of Tang Chang confound categories such as ‘modern’ or ‘contemporary’, while Bagyi Aung Soe, a Burmese painter who died in poverty, and the Filipino filmmaker Rox Lee were unaligned with either liberal-progressive norms or with the transnational vectors of socialist realism that opposed US imperialism in the 20th century. In ‘Misfits’, the question becomes: how do you narrate global artistic trajectories without recourse to the readymade knowledge structures of Western art – that is, without establishing parallels with pop, abstract expressionism or conceptualism?

d14_keimena13_kanehsatake-cmyk.jpg

Alanis Obomsawin, Kanehsatake: 270 Years of Resistance, 1993, screened as part of the ‘Keimena’ film programme at documenta 14. Courtesy: documenta 14 Kassel and Athens

Alanis Obomsawin, Kanehsatake: 270 Years of Resistance, 1993, screened as part of the ‘Keimena’ film programme at documenta 14. Courtesy: documenta 14 Kassel and Athens

The possibility of a ‘global museum’ was predicated on a consensus about the meaning of culture, partially derived from ideas of universal history or humanist universalism. But this desire for a global semiotics was by no means impartial. It’s tempting to find echoes of Malraux’s attempt to dress pillage in humanist garb in François Hollande’s recent pledge to grant asylum to artworks threatened by Daesh, when the EU has been less kind to people fleeing the same menace. The issue of restituting cultural goods other than Nazi-looted art remains largely unaddressed in Germany, despite official requests from Egypt, Iraq and Greece for artworks to be repatriated – with the Ishtar Gate, the bust of Nefertiti and the Pergamon Altar being just some of the most high-profile examples.

Policies of inclusion seek to atone for past Eurocentrism and histories of subjugation, violence, colonialism and globalization. But they must not overlook the normative dimensions of ‘canon questions’. Individual objects, once collected and assembled inside museums, concretize notions of history, ethnography, cultural heritage, reception and aesthetics. Curatorial approaches, however diverse, adhere to the museum’s own regulation of cultural difference. More keenly, the oppression and exploitation of indigenous peoples tends to be recuperated as the cultural valorization of their heritage. Violence, be it symbolic or material, cannot be undone via inclusion alone. The conceptual categories that buttress the Western canon – authorship, artistic autonomy, value, representation – still require further scrutiny.

In a recent open letter addressed to the ‘viewers, participants and cultural workers’ of documenta 14, the collective Artists Against Evictions accused the exhibition of failing to support migrants and refugees after their precarious shelters were raided by Greek authorities. Yet, the experiences of migrants are explored in a significant portion of the works included in the show. This tension between representation and real life was also felt at the organizational level. The opening press conference made manifest the exhibition’s straddling of opposing directions: one occupied with questions of curatorial positioning and method; the other signalling an interest in matters relating to arts infrastructure and public space. Outside of the traditional exhibition sections of documenta, ‘Keimena’, a film programme curated by Hila Peleg, is to be screened on the public channel ERT2. Other projects include the radio series curated by Bonaventure Soh Bejeng Ndikung and an ambitious public programme organized by Paul B. Preciado. As these instances suggest, shared culture and collective history might find a more suitable medium beyond the secluded museum and the norms of exhibition-making. Might the aspirations of the ‘global museum’ be better attained outside of it altogether? 

Main image: Rox Lee, Juan Gapang (Johny Crawl), Untitled, 1987, from the exhibition ‘Misfits’ at HKW. Courtesy: the artist and HKW, Berlin

Ana Teixeira Pinto is a writer from Lisbon who lives in Berlin. She is currently finishing her PhD at Humboldt University, and is a regular contributor to frieze d/e, Art Agenda and Mousse, among other publications.

Issue 188

First published in Issue 188

June - August 2017

Most Read

With the 12th edition of the itinerant European biennial opening in Palermo, what do local artists, curators and...
In the age of Brexit, why Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn’s pledge to return the ‘stolen’ Parthenon marbles has never been...
The museum director, who resigned last year, acted with ‘integrity’, an independent report finds
In further news: study finds US film critics overwhelmingly white and male; woman sues father over Basquiat
With the government’s push for the controversial English baccalaureate, why the arts should be an integral part of the...
From Bruce Nauman at the Schaulager to the story of a 1970s artist community in Carona at Weiss Falk, all the shows to...
Sotheby’s and Christie’s say they are dropping the practice of using female-only staff to pose for promotional...
For the annual city-wide art weekender ahead of Basel, the best shows and events to attend around town
For our second report from BB10, ahead of its public opening tomorrow, a focus on KW Institute for Contemporary Art
The curators seem set to ask, ‘how civilized is the world’s current state of affairs?’
In further news: declining UK museum visitors sees country fall in world rankings; first winner of Turner Prize,...
The Icelandic-Danish artist’s creation in Vejle, Denmark, responds to the tides and surface of the water: both artwork...
In further news: Emperor Constantine’s missing finger discovered in the Louvre; and are Van Gogh’s Sunflowers turning...
The opening of a major new exhibition by Lee Bul was delayed after one of the South Korean artist’s works caught fire
The LA-based painter’s exquisite skewing of Renaissance and biblical scenes at Stuart Shave/Modern Art, London
Lee Bul, Abortion, 1989, performance documentation. Courtesy: the artist and PKM Gallery, Seoul
In a climate of perma-outrage has live art self-censored to live entertainment?

A tribute to the iconic New York journal: a platform through which founder Andy Warhol operated as artist, hustler and...
A distinctively American artist who, along with four neighbourhood contemporaries, changed the course of US painting...
From Assemble’s marbled floor tiles to Peter Zumthor's mixed-media miniatures, Emily King reports from the main...
From Ian White's posthumous retrospective to Lloyd Corporation's film about a cryptocurrency pyramid scheme, what to...
Kimberly Bradley speaks to ‘the German’ curator on the reasons for his early exit from the Austrian institution
In further news: #MeToo flashmob at Venice Architecture Biennale; BBC historian advocates for return of British...
German museums are being pushed to diversify their canons and respond to a globalized world – but is ‘cleaning up’ the...
Sophie Fiennes’s new film Bloodlight and Bami reveals a personal side of the singer as yet unseen 
‘At last there is a communal mechanism for women to call a halt to the demeaning conventions of machismo’
The German artist has put up 18 works for sale to raise money to buy 100 homes
The novelist explored Jewish identity in the US through a lens of frustrated heterosexuality
Artist Jesse Jones, who represented Ireland at last year’s Venice Biennale, on what is at stake in Friday’s Irish...
‘I spend more time being seduced by the void … as a way of energizing my language’: poet Wayne Koestenbaum speaks about...
To experience the music of the composer, who passed away last week at the age of 69, was to hear something tense,...
In a year charged with politicized tensions, mastery of craft trumps truth-to-power commentary
In further news: women wearing rainbow badges beaten in Beijing’s 798; gallerists Georg Kargl and Richard Gray have...
‘Coping as a woman in France is a daily battle: the aggression can be subtle, and you always have to push harder to...
Toyin Ojih Odutola’s portraits of a fictional aristocratic Nigerian family push toward an expanded definition...

On View

Latest Magazines

frieze magazine

April 2018

frieze magazine

May 2018

frieze magazine

June - August 2018