Is Netflix vs Cannes a Dispute Over the Future of Cinema?

Netflix is actively and self-servingly restricting the platforms films can occupy, but it’s not the only one grumbling about Cannes’s fussy rules

Last year Netflix arrived to Cannes Film Festival with two high-profile titles – Bong Joon-ho’s Okja and Noah Baumbach’s The Meyerowitz Stories (New and Selected) (both 2017) – which, per the company’s policy, would not be eligible to show in French theatres (French law states that 36 months must elapse between a film’s theatrical run and introduction to a Select Video on Demand (SVOD) platform like Netflix). Cannes agreed to allow the two films in the competition that year but warned they probably wouldn't do so in the future. This year, Cannes has followed through: five Netflix titles, including Alfonso Cuarón’s Roma and Jeremy Saulnier’s Hold the Dark, will not be shown in the festival which begins today.

Speaking to Variety, Netflix’s chief content officer Ted Sarandos mocked Cannes’s decision as being as technologically out-of-step as the festival’s ban on red carpet selfies (Netflix CEO Reed Hastings attempted a gentler tone last week, saying ‘sometimes we make mistakes’). For Cannes artistic director Thierry Frémaux, the theatrical experience is a cultural question: ‘The specificity of France is that it asks Cannes to only put films in Competition that are free to be shown theatrically. The consequence of the chronology means it comes out three years later. Sure, it’s absurd […] but for now, we are where we are.’

bong-joon-ho-okja.jpg

Bong Joon-ho, Okja, 2017, film still. Courtesy: Netflix

Bong Joon-ho, Okja, 2017, film still. Courtesy: Netflix

Predictably, both sides in this dispute are eliding key context (it’s always best to be wary of any corporation claiming decisions favouring its bottom line are really ones looking out for its consumers). Note Netflix’s language in a letter to its shareholders: ‘The festival adopted a new rule that means if a film is in competition at Cannes, it cannot be watched on Netflix in France for the following three years. We would never want to do that to our French members.’ Do that to… Netflix is a custodian of the people. But if the company’s primary goal is to get ‘arthouse-leaning’ films to the largest number of people who wouldn’t otherwise have access anytime soon – those in locations without specialist cinemas for instance – then presumably Netflix should have agreed to screen its films in the non-competition sections of the festival (a proposal Cannes offered) which would allow for a day-and-date release, and allow Netflix coverage for its films.

Omitted from Netflix’s virtuous self-portrait is the company’s broader relationship to festivals, which, to festival directors, reads as a fairly opportunistic hijacking of those platforms for promotional purposes. ‘Netflix does not see value in the existing domestic film-community infrastructure to audiences,’ an anonymous film festival director complained to Business Insider, ‘but they seem to want the credibility that this infrastructure lends to their prestige projects without having to fully participate in the community.’ In France, legislation was introduced which would require Netflix to pay a 2% tax on subscription revenue, which would be plugged back into the budget of the CNC, the state body which finances many French productions. Netflix contested a similar law in Germany.

thierry-fremaux-cannes2.jpg

Thierry Fremaux, Director of Cannes Film Festival. Courtesy: Cannes Film Festival

Thierry Frémaux, Artistic Director of Cannes Film Festival. Courtesy: Cannes Film Festival

In the US, Netflix is notorious among bookers for not allowing theatres to screen their films. Not the multiplex chains who refused to book their day-and-date (released online and in theatres at the same time) films, but the numerous independent and arthouse theatres who’ve asked to do so. There are inconsistent exceptions (limited big-city releases of especially prestigious titles, documentary bookings for community organization screenings), but the theatrical option has largely been taken off the table. ‘We tried for years to program titles that debut on Netflix, regardless of whether they're already streaming or not,’ says Chris Hemel, president of Columbus, Ohio’s Gateway Film Center, which has attempted to screen Netflix films including Mudbound, The Meyerowitz Stories and Angelina Jolie’s First They Killed My Father. ‘We've reached out directly to Netflix representatives and typically they are completely non-responsive. When they use third-party booking agents, which in many cases we have relationships with, I think the agents really try to go to bat for us to try to allow us to book the films, with no success.’

Sarandos is cleverly moving the goalposts when declaring that ‘we are choosing to be about the future of cinema. If Cannes is choosing to be stuck in the history of cinema, that’s fine.’ That ‘future,’ as Netflix envisions it, is now, as the company actively works to make the theatrical presentation of a film a charming but fundamentally anachronistic pursuit. For Netflix this isn’t some abstract argument about changing definitions of ‘cinema,’ as Sarandos tries to paint it, but an active restriction of how many platforms it can occupy.

alfonso-cuaron.jpg

Director Alfonso Cuarón’s latest film Roma, will not sceen at Cannes this year.

Director Alfonso Cuarón’s latest film Roma, will not sceen at Cannes this year.

For his part, Frémaux may sound more credible (if almost laughably French) when saying things like ‘my responsibility is cinema,’ but what he’s alluding to when talking about changing the rules is much more specific, a reform process that’s been in the works for a while. There’s been increasing grumbling from French distributors about the many long embargoes currently placed on films in the country; not just the 36-month window that applies to subscription video on demand (SVOD) services like Netflix, but, for instance, the four months between the start of theatrical release and any VOD availability. It’s not quite accurate for Frémaux to paint the dispute as one solely between Netflix and Cannes; the former’s complaints aren’t as exceptional as the latter would have them be. Buried within Frémaux’s defence is an assumption that the platform Cannes provides then leads to healthy theatrical runs in France for the kind of films it champions: determining whether this is actually true would require a long-term review of French box office returns over the decades vis-a-vis the various technological disruptions Netflix represents.

The dispute is less between two futures of cinema and is more a particularly localized powerplay. Despite its commitment to a rigidly defined, arguably conservative roster of Great Arthouse Masters, Cannes deserves less ire for its position than it has received. Yet, legislation changing theatrical windows is almost certainly coming. Netflix’s ongoing, quiet aversion to allowing theatrical booking (unlike Amazon, which has actively expanded in the field) is not just a fight with French legislation generally or Cannes specifically, it is at odds with theatres around the world. Whomever is to win out in this squabble in the long run, this conflict shouldn’t be read as a stand in for the larger question: whether film’s theatrical experience will or will not survive.

Vadim Rizov (@vrizov) is the managing editor of Filmmaker Magazine.

Most Read

Royal bodies, the ‘incel’ mindset and those Childish Gambino hot-takes: what to read this weekend
In further news: women wearing rainbow badges beaten in Beijing’s 798; gallerists Georg Kargl and Richard Gray have...
‘Coping as a woman in France is a daily battle: the aggression can be subtle, and you always have to push harder to...
The rapper and artist have thoughts about originality in art; Melania Trump tries graphic design – all the latest...
The dilapidated Nissen hut from which Rachel Whiteread will take a cast
Yorkshire residents complain that the concrete sculpture of a ‘Nissen hut’ will attract excrement, vandalism and litter
Poul Erik Tøjner pays tribute to Denmark’s most important artist since Asger Jorn
Toyin Ojih Odutola’s portraits of a fictional aristocratic Nigerian family push toward an expanded definition...
Photographer Dragana Jurisic says her account was deactivated after she uploaded an artwork depicting a partially naked...
In further news: open letter protests all-male shortlist for BelgianArtPrize; Arts Council of Ireland issues...
From Sol Calero’s playful clichés of Latin America to an homage to British modernist architect Alison Smithson
Everybody’s favourite underpaid, over-educated, raven-haired art critic, Rhonda Lieberman, is as relevant as ever
‘Prize & Prejudice’ at London's UCL Art Museum is a bittersweet celebration of female talent
The curators want to rectify the biennale’s ‘failure to question the hetero-normative production of space’; ‘poppers...
A fragment of the brutalist Robin Hood Gardens will go on show at the Venice Architecture Biennale
‘Women's role in shaping the history of contemporary art is being reappraised’
Three shows in Ireland celebrate the legendary polymath, artist and author of Inside the White Cube
The legendary performance artists will partner up again to detail their tumultuous relationship in a new book
An open letter signed by over 100 leading artists including 15 Turner prize-winners says that new UK education policy...
Naturists triumph at art gallery; soothing students with colouring books; Kanye’s architectural firm: your dose of art...
Avengers: Infinity War confirms the domination of mass culture by the franchise: what ever happened to narrative...
The agency’s founder talks about warfare in the age of post truth, deconstructing images and holding states and...
From hobnobbing with Oprah to championing new art centres, millennial crown prince Mohammed bin Salman is following a...
A juror for the award last year, Dan Fox on why the Turner Prize is and always will be political (whatever that means)
The argument that ancestral connection offers a natural grasp of the complex histories and aesthetics of African art is...
One of most iconic and controversial writers of the past 40 years, Tom Wolfe discusses writing, art and intellectual...

Latest Magazines

frieze magazine

March 2018

frieze magazine

April 2018

frieze magazine

May 2018